Family Business

    How to Document Reasonable Wages for Your Child When There Is No Comparable Market Rate for the Job

    9 min read

    Paying your child through the family business is one of the most legally straightforward tax strategies available to a sole proprietor or spousal partnership. The hard part is not the payroll mechanics. The hard part shows up when your 11-year-old is doing something genuinely useful for the business, but there is no Bureau of Labor Statistics job code that describes it.

    Say she tests your product prototypes, narrates a voiceover for your brand's Instagram reel, or models for the product photos on your Etsy listing. What is the market rate for that? There is not one. Not a clean one, anyway.

    TL;DR: The IRS requires a "reasonable" wage for your child's work, even when no direct market rate exists. Build that wage by splitting the role into its component tasks, finding third-party rates for each piece, applying an age-appropriate skill adjustment, and documenting every hour. Wages up to the 2026 standard deduction of $16,100 are federally tax-free to the child under IRC §63.

    Want the full 7-step playbook as a PDF?

    Get the same guide my readers use to set this up correctly the first time. Sent to your inbox in 60 seconds.

    Written by the Kids Payroll team, grounded in IRC §3121(b)(3)(A) and current IRS guidance on legitimately employing your children in a family business.

    What "Reasonable Wages" Actually Means When No Market Rate Exists

    Reasonable means what you would pay an unrelated third party for the same work. That is the legal standard, not some vague notion of fairness.

    The Tax Court articulated this in Eller v. Commissioner, 77 T.C. 934 (1981), which allowed deductions for wages paid to children as young as seven for genuine, age-appropriate tasks, but capped the deduction at what was reasonable for that work. The court did not require an exact apples-to-apples job match. It required evidence that the parent thought through what the work was worth, not what they wanted to shift in income.

    When a clean market rate exists (say, a 16-year-old doing data entry at a local staffing rate), you point to that. When it does not, you build the rate from the bottom up. That is what this article covers. For a broader look at the overall wage-setting framework, the reasonable compensation guide for kids payroll is a good starting point, and the wage rate reference guide shows how rates map to specific roles and ages. This article focuses on what to do when neither of those gives you a clean answer.

    The Four-Step Method for Building a Defensible Wage

    Step 1: Break the Role into Its Component Tasks

    Most "unusual" jobs inside a family business are actually bundles of ordinary tasks. A child who models for your product photography is doing three things: showing up on time, following direction on posture and expression, and sitting still through retakes. A child who narrates a podcast intro is doing reading aloud, following audio cues, and re-recording until the take is clean.

    Write each task down. This is not busywork. It is the foundation of your wage defense.

    Step 2: Find Third-Party Rates for Each Component

    For each task, ask: what would I pay a stranger to do this?

    A few places to look:

    • Freelance platforms (search by category, not by exact title): general voiceover work, basic modeling for e-commerce, social media content creation, product testing.
    • Staffing agency rate sheets for office and clerical work: filing, data entry, light assembly.
    • Local business directories or service quotes: cleaning a commercial space, stuffing envelopes for a mailing.

    You do not need a precise market rate. You need a documented reasonable range. Write down where you looked, what you found, and when you looked. A short paragraph in a notes document with the date is enough.

    Step 3: Apply an Age-Appropriate Skill Discount

    A professional voiceover artist charges more than your 10-year-old narrating a 30-second jingle. That gap is real and you should reflect it. A reasonable discount for a child who is learning, who works more slowly, and whose output requires more takes or more supervision might be 30-60% below the adult market rate.

    The discount is not about shortchanging your kid. It is about intellectual honesty. An IRS examiner who sees you paying a nine-year-old $75 an hour for "modeling" because adult models charge that will raise an eyebrow. The same examiner seeing $15 an hour with a note explaining the comparison and the skill-level adjustment will move on.

    Step 4: Lock It in Writing Before the First Paycheck

    Before your child does a single hour of work, write down:

    1. Job title and description (one paragraph describing what the child actually does)
    2. Hourly rate and how it was determined (a sentence pointing to your research)
    3. Expected schedule (hours per week, days)
    4. Start date

    Keep this in a folder, physical or digital, alongside your business records. The IRS documentation guide for kids payroll covers what the IRS expects in a broader audit context. What matters here is that you made the decision before the money moved, not after.

    A Worked Example: Product Modeling for an Etsy Shop

    Here is how this plays out in practice.

    Assumptions:

    • Parent runs an Etsy shop selling handmade children's accessories.
    • Their daughter, age 11, poses for product photos twice a month and helps sort and tag inventory one afternoon a week.
    • The parent researches rates and finds that entry-level e-commerce product models (adults) charge $50-$80 per session locally. Tagging and sorting work at a warehouse would pay roughly $14-$16 per hour.

    Wage-setting logic:

    • Modeling sessions: the parent sets a per-session rate of $20 (a conservative discount from the $50 adult floor, reflecting the child's age, variable output, and sessions that run short).
    • Inventory work: $10 per hour, just below the local adult floor for comparable manual work.

    Hours and earnings:

    • 2 modeling sessions per month x 12 months = 24 sessions x $20 = $480
    • 2 hours per week sorting/tagging x 50 weeks = 100 hours x $10 = $1,000
    • Total annual wages: $1,480

    Tax math:

    • The business deducts $1,480 as a payroll expense. If the parent is in the 22% federal bracket plus pays 15.3% self-employment tax, each dollar of shifted income saves roughly $0.37. Total savings: about $548.
    • The daughter owes zero federal income tax. Her $1,480 in wages falls far below the 2026 standard deduction of $16,100 under IRC §63. No FICA taxes apply because she is employed by her parent's sole proprietorship, which is exempt under IRC §3121(b)(3)(A) for children under 18.
    • If the parent deposits $1,480 into a Roth IRA in the daughter's name, those funds can grow tax-free for decades.

    That is $548 in real tax savings, $1,480 seeded in a Roth, and a kid who is learning what it means to contribute to the family business. Not bad for sorting tags on a Saturday afternoon.

    What the IRS Is Actually Looking For

    The IRS does not audit family wages because no market rate exists. It audits them because documentation is missing, wages are obviously inflated, or the work was personal (household chores dressed up as business tasks).

    When your child's job has no market rate, the examiner's question is: "How did this parent decide what to pay?" Your job is to answer that question with paper, before you are ever asked.

    The records that matter:

    • Time log: date, task, hours. It does not need to be elaborate. A simple spreadsheet works. So does a handwritten notebook, as long as it is contemporaneous, meaning filled in as work happens, not reconstructed from memory later.
    • Written job description: one page, prepared before the work starts.
    • Wage rationale memo: one paragraph explaining how you set the rate and what you compared it to.
    • W-2: required at year-end. If your child funds a Roth IRA, the W-2 is not optional. It is the earned income paper trail that justifies the contribution.

    One thing worth saying plainly: do not issue a 1099-NEC to your child. A 1099 turns the payment into self-employment income, which triggers self-employment tax and eliminates the FICA exemption. The exemption under IRC §3121(b)(3)(A) applies to employees, not independent contractors. Issue a W-2.

    Common Mistakes When No Market Rate Exists

    Setting the wage based on what you want to deduct, not what the work is worth. This is the most common error. The wage should be set before payroll starts, based on the work. Not reverse-engineered from a desired tax outcome.

    Paying for work the child did not do. If your time log shows 8 hours a week but your child is in school 35 hours a week and has sports three afternoons, a skeptical examiner will notice. Keep the hours realistic. Age-appropriate tasks for an 11-year-old might run 2-5 hours a week, maybe more during school breaks.

    Paying through the wrong entity. If your business is structured as an S-Corp, the FICA exemption does not apply directly. You would need a separate Family Management Company structure to preserve it. For more on that, see how the S-Corp family management company setup works.

    Forgetting state taxes. The federal standard deduction may cover your child's wages entirely. State rules are different. California's standard deduction for a dependent is roughly $5,540. New York's is roughly $3,100. Wages above those thresholds may create a state tax liability even when federal tax is zero.

    A Note on Unusual Roles Worth Documenting Carefully

    Some child roles inside family businesses have real business value but no obvious market rate, and the IRS knows it. These include:

    • Appearing in marketing videos or podcasts
    • Modeling for product photography or social media
    • App or product testing and feedback
    • Creating content under parental supervision

    These are legitimate business tasks. There is detailed guidance on paying kids to appear in YouTube videos or podcasts and on paying kids to model for business marketing if either of those applies to your situation. The wage-documentation logic in this article applies to all of them.

    Key Takeaways

    • "Reasonable wages" means what you would pay a third party, not what is most tax-advantageous.
    • When no direct market rate exists, decompose the job into component tasks and research rates for each.
    • Apply an honest age-appropriate discount and document your reasoning before the first paycheck.
    • Keep a contemporaneous time log, a written job description, and a wage rationale memo.
    • Issue a W-2, not a 1099. This is not optional.
    • Wages up to $16,100 in 2026 are federally tax-free to a dependent child under IRC §63.
    • State tax rules vary and may leave the child with a small state liability even when federal tax is zero.

    The Bottom Line

    Honestly, this is the part most parents skip because it feels like homework. But building a rate from first principles, writing it down, and keeping a time log takes maybe two hours of setup and five minutes a week to maintain. That two-hour investment protects years of deductions.

    If you are ready to set up payroll for your child properly, the Kids Payroll app logs the hours, tasks, and pay rate in one place, and your CPA uses that log to prepare the W-2. Create your free account and get the documentation right from day one.


    Frequently Asked Questions

    Can I pay my child for a job that has never been done by anyone else? Yes, as long as the work is real, genuinely serves the business, and the wage reflects what you would pay a third party for comparable effort. Break the role into its component tasks, research rates for each, apply an age-appropriate adjustment, and document your reasoning in writing.

    What if I pay my child too much because I could not find a good market comparison? The IRS will disallow the portion of the wage it considers unreasonable. Only the disallowed excess is at risk, not the entire deduction. The Tax Court in Eller v. Commissioner, 77 T.C. 934 (1981), reduced rather than eliminated the deduction where wages were somewhat inflated but the work was real. The lesson: conservative is safer than aggressive, and documented reasoning protects you either way.

    Do I have to set the wage exactly equal to a market rate I find? No. You need to set a wage you can defend as reasonable, meaning thoughtful, documented, and not obviously inflated. A well-reasoned rate that sits below the adult market comparison, adjusted for your child's age and skill level, is entirely defensible.

    What records do I actually need to keep? At minimum: a written job description prepared before work starts, a contemporaneous time log showing date, task, and hours, a brief memo explaining how you set the wage, and a W-2 at year-end. If your child funds a Roth IRA, the W-2 is the earned income documentation that justifies the contribution.

    Does the FICA tax exemption still apply when there is no market rate for the job? Yes. The FICA exemption under IRC §3121(b)(3)(A) applies based on the employer-employee relationship and the child's age (under 18), not on whether the job has a standard market rate. The exemption is about entity structure and age, not job category.


    Sources

    This article is for educational purposes only and is not tax or legal advice. Consult a qualified CPA before putting your kids on payroll.

    Log the hours as they happen

    Kids Payroll keeps a dated log of every job and hour your child works. In January, hand it to your CPA for the W-2. It doesn't run payroll; it keeps the records.

    Free. No credit card. Start logging hours today.

    Download Kids Payroll on the App StoreGet Kids Payroll on Google Play

    Want the full 7-step playbook as a PDF?

    Get the same guide my readers use to set this up correctly the first time. Sent to your inbox in 60 seconds.