The letter arrives. The IRS has reviewed your return, disallowed the wages you paid your child, and reclassified those payments as gifts. Your deduction is gone. You now owe back taxes, and possibly penalties and interest on top of that.
Written by the Kids Payroll team, grounded in IRC §3121(b)(3)(A) and current IRS guidance on legitimately employing your children in a family business.
This happens more than people expect. The good news is that it is not always the end of the story. You have options. But the best outcome requires understanding exactly why the IRS made this call, what you can do to push back, and how to make sure you are never in this position again.
Want the full 7-step playbook as a PDF?
Get the same guide my readers use to set this up correctly the first time. Sent to your inbox in 60 seconds.
Why the IRS Recharacterizes Child Wages as Gifts
The IRS does not disallow child wages because hiring your kids is illegal. It is perfectly legal. The IRS disallows wages when the payments do not meet the standards of IRC §162, which requires that a business expense be ordinary, necessary, and reasonable.
When the agency looks at a payment from a parent to a child and sees no documentation of real work, wages that are wildly above market rate for the tasks performed, or payments made to a child who is clearly too young to do the job described, it concludes the payment was a gift disguised as wages. Under IRC §102, gifts are not deductible. So the agency flips the characterization, erases your deduction, and sends you a bill.
The Tax Court put a fine point on this in Eller v. Commissioner, 77 T.C. 934 (1981). The court allowed deductions for wages paid to children as young as seven, but only for genuine, age-appropriate work and only at reasonable rates. The lesson from that case is that the IRS will not automatically deny child wages. It will scrutinize them closely. And if the records are not there, you lose.
Common audit triggers include:
- Wages that are disproportionately large relative to the child's age and the tasks described
- No W-2 issued (or a 1099-NEC issued instead, which triggers self-employment tax and signals that the arrangement was not treated as real employment)
- No payroll records, time logs, or job descriptions on file
- Payments made from a personal account rather than a business account
- Paying a child for tasks that are household chores, not business tasks
- Paying children through an S-Corp or C-Corp without the Family Management Company structure that preserves the FICA exemption under IRC §3121(b)(3)(A)
If one or more of those apply to your situation, you can see why the IRS landed where it did. That does not mean the case is closed.
What to Do Immediately After the Disallowance
Act quickly. You have deadlines, and missing them gives up rights you cannot get back.
Step 1: Read the notice carefully.
The IRS will send either a CP2000 (a proposal for changes based on information matching), a 30-day letter (proposing adjustments after an audit), or a 90-day letter, also called a Statutory Notice of Deficiency. The type of notice determines your response window and your options.
Step 2: Do not ignore it and do not just pay it reflexively.
Paying the bill without objecting is an admission that the IRS was right. If you believe the wages were legitimate, you have the right to contest the finding. Many families pay out of fear when they actually had a defensible case. A qualified CPA or tax attorney can tell you quickly whether your facts support a fight.
Step 3: Gather every piece of documentation you have.
Even if your records are thin, pull together what exists. Text messages about work assignments, photos of your child performing tasks, invoices or deliverables they produced, bank records showing transfers from a business account, and any W-2s or payroll reports you filed. Imperfect records are better than none.
Step 4: File a written protest or request an Appeals conference.
If you received a 30-day letter, you can request a conference with IRS Appeals. Appeals is independent from the auditor and often reaches more reasonable outcomes. If you received a 90-day notice, you can petition the United States Tax Court without paying the tax first. This is a significant right. Do not let the 90-day window expire.
For a deeper look at surviving a payroll audit for your children, see our post on IRS audits and kids payroll, which walks through what examiners actually look for and how to respond.
How the IRS Evaluates Whether Child Wages Were Real
At an Appeals conference or in Tax Court, the question comes down to three things: Was the work real? Was the wage reasonable? Are there records?
The IRS does not need all three to be perfect. But it needs enough to believe the arrangement was an arm's-length employment relationship, not a family wealth transfer dressed up as a business expense.
Real work means tasks that have genuine business value. Shredding documents, filming product videos, modeling for marketing photos, entering data, answering customer calls, packaging orders: these qualify. Cleaning the family bathroom, feeding the dog, or doing homework do not. See our breakdown of age-appropriate tasks and legitimate jobs for a full list by age.
Reasonable wages means what you would pay a non-family employee to do the same job. A 10-year-old doing basic data entry earns something close to minimum wage. A 16-year-old editing professional videos can justify a higher rate. Paying a 9-year-old $40,000 a year is not going to survive scrutiny, regardless of how detailed your records are.
Records means time logs, job descriptions, a written offer letter or contract, pay stubs, and a W-2 at year end. These do not need to be elaborate. A simple spreadsheet tracking hours and tasks per week, combined with a one-page job description, covers a lot of ground.
A Concrete Example of What This Costs You
Say you paid your 14-year-old daughter $10,000 in wages for managing your business social media accounts in 2023. You are a sole proprietor in the 24% federal bracket. You deducted $10,000 as a business expense, saving $2,400 in income tax.
The IRS audits you. You cannot produce time logs or a job description. The examiner recharacterizes the $10,000 as a gift. You lose the $10,000 deduction. Your taxable income rises by $10,000, costing you $2,400 in back taxes. The IRS also asserts an accuracy-related penalty of 20% of the underpayment under IRC §6662, adding $480. Plus interest accrues from the original due date of the return.
Total cost of not having documentation: $2,400 in taxes, $480 in penalties, and however many months of interest. All of it was preventable with a simple time log and a W-2.
Rebuilding Your Setup the Right Way Going Forward
Whether you won the audit, settled it, or paid the bill and moved on, the only smart next step is to build a payroll arrangement the IRS cannot touch.
The key requirements are not complicated. They just require consistency.
- Assign real, documented job roles. Write a one-page description of what your child does, how many hours per week, and what the deliverable looks like. Update it if the role changes.
- Keep weekly time logs. Even a photo of a handwritten log or a shared Google Sheet is enough. The goal is evidence that the hours happened.
- Pay through a business bank account, on a regular schedule. Sporadic cash payments from a personal account look like allowances, not payroll.
- Issue a W-2 at year end. If your child has a Roth IRA funded with these wages, a W-2 is non-negotiable. It documents earned income, which is the only basis for a Roth IRA contribution.
- Match the wage to the market rate for the task. Use job sites or local postings to support the rate you chose.
- Use the right entity structure. If your business is a sole proprietorship, single-member LLC, or a spousal partnership, your child under 18 is exempt from FICA under IRC §3121(b)(3)(A) and FUTA under IRC §3306(c)(5). If your business is an S-Corp or C-Corp, you need a Family Management Company to preserve those exemptions. Paying kids directly from a corporation without that structure is one of the most common mistakes we see.
Our full post on IRS documentation for kids' payroll goes into the specific records the IRS expects to see and how to organize them.
And if you are still asking whether this whole strategy is on solid legal ground, our post on whether paying your kids is legal addresses the skepticism head-on.
What Happens to the Child's Tax Return If the Wages Are Disallowed?
This is a piece most people miss. If the IRS disallows the wages at the parent level, the child's W-2 income may also need to be amended. The child did not actually earn wages, from the IRS's perspective. If the child filed a return reporting that W-2 income and funded a Roth IRA based on it, you may have a secondary problem.
Roth IRA contributions must not exceed the child's earned income for the year (IRC §408A, cross-referencing earned income rules). If the wages are disallowed, the child's earned income drops. If contributions now exceed earned income, the excess is subject to a 6% annual excise tax under IRC §4973 until removed.
This is another reason to fight a disallowance if you have a real case. The ripple effects go beyond the parent's deduction.
Key Takeaways
- The IRS recharacterizes child wages as gifts when work is not real, wages are unreasonable, or records do not exist.
- You can contest the disallowance through IRS Appeals or the United States Tax Court.
- Acting before the 90-day deadline on a Statutory Notice of Deficiency is critical.
- Even imperfect documentation is worth presenting at an Appeals conference.
- Going forward, the fix is simple: real tasks, reasonable rates, a W-2, and a paper trail.
- A disallowance at the parent level can create excess Roth IRA contribution problems at the child level. Address both.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I still deduct my child's wages if I missed some payroll records? Possibly. IRS Appeals weighs all available evidence. Partial records, corroborating photos, bank transfers, and testimony about the work performed can collectively support your case. It is harder without complete records, but not automatically hopeless.
Does the IRS automatically audit families that pay their kids? No. But wages paid to family members receive heightened scrutiny because the IRS knows these arrangements can be abused. Returns with disproportionately large child wages relative to the business's gross income are more likely to attract attention.
What is the difference between a CP2000 and a 90-day letter? A CP2000 is a proposal based on information matching, not yet a formal assessment. You can respond with documentation and it may be resolved without a formal audit. A 90-day letter (Statutory Notice of Deficiency) is a formal IRS determination. You have 90 days to petition the Tax Court, or the assessment becomes final.
If the wages are recharacterized as gifts, does my child owe gift tax? No. The annual gift tax exclusion ($18,000 per recipient in 2025, indexed for inflation) covers most or all of what a parent would pay a child in a legitimate payroll arrangement. Gift tax, if it ever applied, would fall on the giver (the parent), not the recipient. And it is only triggered if gifts exceed the annual exclusion.
Can I rehire my child and start fresh after a disallowance? Yes. A disallowance applies to the year under audit. You can set up a proper arrangement for the current and future years. The key is doing it right this time: real job description, documented hours, payroll through the business, and a W-2 at year end.
The Bottom Line
If the IRS disallowed your child's wages, the first step is to understand exactly why, then decide whether you have enough to push back. Many families do. Request an Appeals conference before paying anything you are not certain you owe.
And whether or not you fight the current disallowance, rebuild the arrangement on solid ground going forward. Time logs, job descriptions, a business bank account, and a W-2 are not bureaucratic overhead. They are the difference between a deduction that sticks and one that gets reversed three years later with penalties attached.
The Kids Payroll app is designed to make that documentation automatic. Sign up and start running payroll for your kids the way the IRS expects to see it.
Sources
- IRC §162, Ordinary and necessary business expenses
- IRC §102, Gifts and inheritances
- IRC §3121(b)(3)(A), FICA exemption for child employed by parent
- IRC §3306(c)(5), FUTA exemption for child under 21
- IRC §4973, Excise tax on excess IRA contributions
- IRC §6662, Accuracy-related penalty
- IRS Publication 15, Employer's Tax Guide
- IRS Publication 501 (Dependents, Standard Deduction, and Filing Information)
- Eller v. Commissioner, 77 T.C. 934 (1981)
This article is for educational purposes only and is not tax or legal advice. Consult a qualified CPA before putting your kids on payroll.