Comparison

    QuickBooks Payroll vs Gusto for Paying Your Kids (and Where Kids Payroll Fits)

    January 2026
    9 min read

    Last updated: November 2026

    Quick answer

    Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll both run payroll, file payroll taxes and make W-2s. QuickBooks Payroll fits best if you already keep your books in QuickBooks Online; Gusto is standalone payroll that connects to your accounting software. When the employee is your child under 18 and your business is a sole prop or parent-owned LLC, the setting that matters in either one is marking the wages exempt from Social Security and Medicare (15.3%) and FUTA.

    Want the full 7-step playbook as a PDF?

    Get the same guide my readers use to set this up correctly the first time. Sent to your inbox in 60 seconds.

    If you're paying your kids through your business, you've probably wondered whether you need real payroll software like Gusto or QuickBooks Payroll, and which one.

    Here's an honest answer, including where our own app fits. Kids Payroll is not payroll software. It logs your child's hours and tasks. Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll run payroll. They do different jobs, and plenty of families use one of each, or no payroll software at all.


    Quick Comparison

    Kids PayrollGustoQuickBooks Payroll
    What it isA log of your child's workFull payroll servicePayroll add-on to QuickBooks
    Runs payroll and pays employeesNo, you pay your childYesYes
    Files payroll taxesNoYesYes
    Makes W-2sNo, your CPA prepares itYesYes
    Logs each date, task and hour of your child's workYes, built for thisNot built for family employmentNot built for family employment
    CostFree to create an accountMonthly plans; check Gusto's current pricingMonthly plans; check QuickBooks' current pricing

    QuickBooks Payroll vs Gusto

    Both are full payroll services. Either one can pay your child, withhold what needs withholding, file payroll tax forms, and produce a W-2 at year-end. The real difference is how they fit the rest of your business.

    Choose QuickBooks Payroll if your books already live in QuickBooks Online. Payroll then posts straight into your accounting, and your CPA sees wages and the business deduction in one place.

    Choose Gusto if you want payroll as its own tool. Gusto is standalone and connects to accounting software, including QuickBooks Online and Xero. Some owners find it easier to use when they rarely touch payroll.

    Either is overkill if your only employees are your kids and you have no other staff. More on that below.

    Plans and prices change often, so compare the current plans on each company's site before you sign up.


    Setting Up Your Child in Either One

    Payroll software treats every new employee like an adult stranger unless you tell it otherwise. The settings that matter for your child:

    1. Check your entity first. The exemptions apply when the employer is your sole proprietorship, a single-member LLC taxed as a disregarded entity, or a partnership where every partner is a parent of the child. See the FICA exemption for minor children.
    2. Social Security and Medicare: exempt for a child under 18 (IRC Section 3121(b)(3)(A)). That's the 15.3% FICA tax, 7.65% from you and 7.65% from your child.
    3. FUTA: exempt for a child under 21 (IRC Section 3306(c)(5)).
    4. State unemployment: rules vary by state, so confirm with your CPA.
    5. W-4: if your child will owe no federal income tax (wages up to the $16,100 standard deduction in 2026), they can claim exempt so nothing is withheld. They may still owe state income tax.
    6. Turn the exemption off at 18. Social Security and Medicare apply to work done after the 18th birthday. Here's what changes when your child turns 18.

    If you can't find where to mark an employee exempt, ask the provider's support team or your CPA before you run the first payroll. Getting it wrong means FICA comes out of your child's pay that never needed to.

    S corp or C corp? Don't mark anything exempt. Wages from an S corp or C corp are still deductible but get no FICA or FUTA exemption at any age. The workaround is a family management company: a parent-owned sole prop or LLC that bills the corporation a real fee for real services and employs the kids. It has to be a real business with real work, so set it up with your CPA.


    Do You Need Payroll Software at All?

    Not always. If your kids are your only employees, many families skip payroll software entirely:

    • You pay your child a reasonable wage for real work, by transfer to an account in their name.
    • You keep a dated log of the work and the pay.
    • At year-end, your CPA prepares the W-2 and W-3 and tells you which payroll forms apply to you (for example Form 941 or 944).

    Payroll software makes more sense once you have adult employees, need benefits, or pay people in several states. For the step-by-step version of the simple route, see how to run payroll for your child.


    Where Kids Payroll Fits

    Whether you use Gusto, QuickBooks Payroll, or no payroll software, you still need proof that your child did real work. Payroll software records what you paid. It doesn't record what your 12-year-old actually did on Tuesday afternoon.

    That's the gap Kids Payroll fills. It logs each date, task and hour, so your records show the work behind every paycheck. That's the kind of documentation the IRS looks for, and it's what your CPA or your payroll software needs to get the W-2 right.

    Kids Payroll does:

    • Log each date, task and hour your child works
    • Keep that record organized for you and your CPA

    Kids Payroll doesn't:

    • Run payroll, pay your child, or withhold taxes
    • File payroll taxes
    • Make or file W-2s

    You and your CPA (or Gusto or QuickBooks Payroll) handle:

    • Paying your child
    • W-2 preparation and filing
    • Any payroll tax filings that apply

    How Kids Payroll Helps

    Kids Payroll logs each date, task and hour your child works, so your CPA has what they need for the W-2, whether payroll runs through Gusto, QuickBooks, or your CPA. It's free to create an account.

    Create your free account. Kids Payroll logs the hours; you pay your child; your CPA or payroll software prepares the W-2.


    FAQ

    Is QuickBooks Payroll or Gusto better for paying my kids?

    Both run payroll, file payroll taxes and make W-2s. QuickBooks Payroll is the natural pick if your books are already in QuickBooks Online; Gusto is standalone payroll that connects to accounting software. For your kids, the setup matters more than the brand.

    Can I use Gusto to pay my child?

    Yes. Make sure your child's employee record is set up so Social Security, Medicare and FUTA are not taken out when your business qualifies for the family exemption. If you can't find the setting, ask Gusto support or your CPA.

    Does QuickBooks Payroll handle the FICA exemption for my child?

    QuickBooks Payroll can run payroll for your child, but you have to set the employee's tax exemptions correctly. A child under 18 paid by a sole prop, single-member LLC, or parents-only partnership is exempt from Social Security and Medicare, and from FUTA until 21.

    Do I need payroll software to pay my child?

    No. Many families with only their kids on payroll pay their child directly and have their CPA prepare the W-2 and any required payroll forms from a log of hours and pay.

    Does Kids Payroll run payroll or make W-2s?

    No. Kids Payroll logs each date, task and hour your child works. You pay your child yourself, and your CPA or your payroll software prepares the W-2.

    I have an S corp. Do these exemptions apply?

    No. Wages from an S corp or C corp are deductible but get no FICA or FUTA exemption at any age, so don't mark them exempt in Gusto or QuickBooks. The workaround is a family management company that bills the corporation a real fee and employs the kids. Ask your CPA.


    Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute tax or legal advice. Consult a qualified CPA or tax professional for guidance specific to your situation.

    Log the hours as they happen

    Kids Payroll keeps a dated log of every job and hour your child works. In January, hand it to your CPA for the W-2. It doesn't run payroll; it keeps the records.

    Free. No credit card. Start logging hours today.

    Download Kids Payroll on the App StoreGet Kids Payroll on Google Play

    Want the full 7-step playbook as a PDF?

    Get the same guide my readers use to set this up correctly the first time. Sent to your inbox in 60 seconds.